Last Updated: October 25, 2026
Quick Summary
How do you know whether your financial adviser is delivering value? The answer involves more than looking at your investment returns.
At Veyron Wealth Group, our approach is built around a simple principle: use a disciplined, benchmark-based investment strategy to capture market returns efficiently, then add value through the financial strategy surrounding those investments.
Research from S&P Dow Jones Indices’ SPIVA scorecards consistently shows that most actively managed funds struggle to outperform their relevant benchmarks over longer periods. This supports the case for diversified, cost-conscious benchmark investing rather than relying on the ability of fund managers to consistently pick winning investments.
But investment returns are only part of the picture. A financial adviser should also help you structure your wealth, make informed decisions about superannuation and tax, prepare for retirement, manage cash flow and avoid costly behavioural mistakes.
Here are seven steps to help you evaluate your financial adviser and understand the value you receive.
Why Evaluating Your Financial Adviser’s Performance Matters
You engage a financial adviser to help you make better financial decisions and work towards your long-term goals. Yet many investors judge their adviser primarily by whether their portfolio has increased in value.
That can be misleading.
When markets rise, a diversified portfolio should generally benefit from its exposure to the relevant markets. When markets fall, even a well-constructed portfolio may lose value. Neither outcome, on its own, tells you whether your adviser is doing a good job.
At Veyron Wealth Group, we believe clients should understand two distinct questions:
- Investment performance: Is my portfolio delivering an appropriate return relative to its investment strategy, market benchmarks, risk and costs?
- Financial strategy: Is my adviser helping me make better decisions about my wealth and improve the likelihood of achieving my financial goals?
Our benchmark-based investment philosophy is designed to capture market returns without relying on the assumption that an active fund manager will consistently outperform. Our value as advisers lies in helping clients determine which markets and assets they should invest in, how much risk they should take, how their investments fit into their broader financial position and how to stay on course.
Step 1: Understand Benchmark Investing and Why It Matters
Benchmark investing starts with a straightforward idea: rather than trying to predict which individual shares or fund managers will outperform, investors can use diversified investments designed to track relevant market indices.
For example, an investment tracking a broad Australian share market index aims to deliver returns reflecting that market, before allowing for investment costs and tracking differences. International share investments can provide exposure to global markets, while bond and cash investments can serve different roles within a diversified portfolio.
This approach differs from traditional active management, where fund managers select investments in an attempt to outperform a benchmark.
Active managers can outperform, and some do. However, consistently identifying those managers in advance is difficult. Active management also generally involves a higher cost hurdle: managers must generate sufficient additional performance to compensate for their fees and other costs.
The SPIVA research published by S&P Dow Jones Indices measures actively managed funds against relevant benchmarks across markets and investment categories.
In its Australia Year-End 2025 scorecard, SPIVA reported that 74% of Australian Equity General funds underperformed the S&P/ASX 200 over the year. Over 15 years, 87% underperformed. In global equities, more than 95% of funds underperformed their benchmark over the 10- and 15-year periods covered by the report.
These results do not mean every active manager will underperform, or that benchmark investing will always produce the highest return. They demonstrate how difficult it can be for active managers to outperform consistently over time.
You can read the research at S&P Dow Jones Indices – SPIVA Australia.
For investors, the practical question is whether paying higher fees for active management is justified by the results delivered. If a portfolio is designed to capture market returns, you should expect its performance to be reasonably consistent with its chosen benchmark after accounting for fees, cash holdings, asset allocation and other differences.

Step 2: Compare Your Portfolio With the Right Benchmark
Once you understand the role of benchmarks, the next step is to assess whether your portfolio is delivering the returns you should reasonably expect.
The benchmark must reflect your actual investment strategy. Comparing a conservative portfolio with a share market index, for example, would be inappropriate because the portfolio is not designed to take the same level of risk.
Different investment exposures require different benchmarks:
- Australian shares: A relevant Australian share market index, such as the S&P/ASX 200 Accumulation Index.
- International shares: An appropriate global equity index, taking currency exposure and hedging into account.
- Fixed interest: A suitable bond market index.
- Cash: An appropriate cash rate or cash investment benchmark.
- Diversified portfolios: A blended benchmark reflecting the portfolio’s strategic asset allocation.
For a diversified portfolio, the benchmark should generally reflect the proportions allocated to each asset class. A portfolio holding 60% growth assets and 40% defensive assets should not automatically be judged against a 100% share market index.
Review your performance over several periods:
| Period | What it helps you understand |
|---|---|
| One year | Recent results and market conditions |
| Three years | Medium-term performance |
| Five years | Longer-term consistency |
| Ten years or since inception | Performance across a broader range of market conditions |
Returns should ideally include investment income and distributions, and comparisons should use consistent calculation methods. You should also understand whether portfolio returns are shown before or after investment fees.
If your portfolio is designed to track a benchmark but consistently falls well behind it, ask your adviser to explain the difference. Fees, cash holdings, asset allocation, currency movements and implementation can all contribute.
The aim is not to beat the benchmark at any cost. It is to understand whether your investments are doing the job they were selected to do.
Step 3: Assess Risk, Diversification and Asset Allocation
Benchmark investing does not mean investing everything in one index or taking the maximum available investment risk.
The appropriate portfolio depends on your objectives, investment timeframe, capacity to absorb losses and need for accessible funds.
A younger investor accumulating wealth may be able to tolerate greater short-term volatility than someone who depends on their portfolio to fund retirement spending. Someone approaching retirement may need to consider how market falls could affect the timing of withdrawals.
Your adviser should help establish an appropriate strategic asset allocation across growth assets, defensive assets and cash reserves.
Review the following:
- Is the portfolio diversified across appropriate asset classes and markets?
- Does the investment mix match your risk tolerance and timeframe?
- Are investment costs reasonable?
- Has the asset allocation drifted materially from its target?
- Is rebalancing appropriate, taking account of costs and tax?
- Do you have sufficient liquidity for planned expenses and withdrawals?
Rebalancing involves bringing a portfolio back towards its intended allocation when market movements cause it to drift. It should be guided by a clear strategy rather than an attempt to predict short-term market movements.
For retirees, the role of cash and defensive investments deserves particular attention. Having appropriate reserves can reduce the need to sell growth assets during a market downturn to meet immediate spending requirements.
A successful investment strategy is not necessarily the portfolio with the highest return in a given year. It is the portfolio designed to help you pursue your goals while taking an appropriate level of risk.
Step 4: Evaluate the Fees You Pay and the Value You Receive
Fees matter because every dollar paid in investment and advice costs is a dollar that is no longer available to compound for your benefit.
Your total investment costs may include fund management fees, platform administration, transaction costs and other product charges. Financial advice fees are separate and should be assessed against the services provided.
Ask your adviser to explain your costs in dollar terms, including which services are covered and whether any additional charges may apply.
Benchmark investing can help reduce reliance on higher-cost active management, but low investment costs are only one part of an effective financial plan. The cheapest portfolio is not automatically the most suitable, and the lowest-cost advice service may not provide the planning support you require.
At Veyron, we believe the value of advice lies in the decisions made around your investments as well as the investments themselves.
For example, an adviser may help you determine how much to contribute to superannuation, structure retirement income, manage cash flow, assess debt repayment options or coordinate investments with your tax position. Depending on your circumstances, these decisions can materially affect your overall financial position.
The right question is not simply, “Did my adviser beat the market?”
It is also, “Am I paying a reasonable amount for an appropriate investment strategy and the financial planning support I need?”
Step 5: Ask the Right Questions at Your Review
Your review meeting should give you a clear understanding of how your portfolio is performing and whether your financial strategy remains appropriate.
Consider asking the following questions.
About investment performance
- What benchmark is my portfolio designed to follow?
- How have my investments performed against that benchmark?
- What are my returns over one, three and five years?
- Are the figures shown after investment fees?
- If performance differs from the benchmark, what explains the difference?
About the investment strategy
- Is my asset allocation still appropriate?
- How are my investments diversified?
- When should my portfolio be rebalanced?
- What role do cash and defensive assets play in my strategy?
- Are there any unnecessary costs or complexities in my portfolio?
About financial strategy
- Am I on track to achieve my financial goals?
- Is my superannuation strategy appropriate?
- Could my cash flow or debt position be improved?
- Are there tax considerations that should influence my decisions?
- What should I do now to prepare for retirement or another major goal?
About advice fees
- What am I paying for financial advice?
- Which services are included?
- What practical value has the advice delivered?
- Are there areas where my strategy could be simplified?
Your adviser should be able to explain the reasoning behind recommendations and acknowledge when there is uncertainty. You do not need to understand every technical detail, but you should understand why the strategy is appropriate for you.
Step 6: Evaluate the Value of the Financial Strategy
This is where the difference between investment management and financial advice becomes most important.
A benchmark-based portfolio can provide broad market exposure, diversification and a disciplined approach to investment costs. But it does not, by itself, determine how much you need to invest, which assets should be held inside or outside superannuation, when you can retire or how to turn your wealth into sustainable income.
Those are financial planning questions.
A good adviser helps connect your investments with the rest of your financial life.
Wealth creation: Are you saving and investing in a way that supports your long-term objectives?
Superannuation: Are your contributions, investment options and retirement arrangements appropriate for your circumstances and the applicable rules?
Retirement planning: Do you understand how much you may be able to spend, how income may be generated and how your assets could support you over time?
Cash flow: Are your income, spending, debt repayments and savings working together effectively?
Risk management: Have relevant financial risks been considered, including the potential impact of unexpected events?
Behaviour: Are you maintaining a disciplined approach during market volatility rather than making impulsive decisions that could damage long-term outcomes?
These questions help determine whether your financial strategy is working as a whole. The adviser’s contribution is not simply to select investments that might outperform the market. It is to help you make informed decisions and avoid mistakes that could undermine your objectives.
Step 7: Review Service Quality and Keep Your Plan Current
Investment performance and financial strategy need to be supported by a reliable adviser relationship.
Evaluate whether your adviser communicates clearly, responds within a reasonable timeframe, explains fees and recommendations, and adapts your plan when your circumstances change.
Your adviser should understand your priorities, not just the value of your portfolio.
An annual review is a useful starting point, although the appropriate frequency depends on your needs and circumstances. More frequent discussions may be warranted as you approach retirement, experience a major life event or need to make an important financial decision.
Use a simple checklist before each review:
- My portfolio is compared with an appropriate benchmark.
- Investment returns and fees are clearly explained.
- My risk profile and asset allocation remain appropriate.
- My financial goals and progress are reviewed.
- My superannuation and cash flow strategy are considered.
- My adviser explains the reasoning behind recommendations.
- I understand the next steps and actions required.
If you have concerns, raise them directly. A review should be a constructive discussion about what is working, what needs attention and whether your strategy remains suitable.
How Veyron Wealth Group Approaches Investment Performance
At Veyron Wealth Group, our philosophy is built around the principle of “boring money, exciting life.” We believe investing should support your life rather than become a constant source of anxiety or speculation.
Benchmark-based investing provides a disciplined foundation for seeking appropriate market returns without relying on the ability of active managers to consistently outperform. We also recognise that benchmarks are not guarantees, markets can fall and the right investment mix differs from one person to another.
Our CARE® Investment Philosophy brings together Core Investments, Active Investments, Reserves and Enhanced Returns within a broader strategy tailored to the client. The specific role and weighting of each component depend on the client’s circumstances and objectives.
Our focus is to help you understand why you hold your investments, how much risk you are taking and how your portfolio fits into your broader financial plan.
We do not believe the value of financial advice should be judged solely by whether an adviser beats the market. We believe clients should receive an appropriate investment strategy, clear explanations of costs and performance, and financial planning that helps them make better decisions about their wealth.
If you would like to review your current arrangements, Veyron Wealth Group can help you assess your investment strategy and the role it plays in achieving your financial goals.
General Disclaimer
This article contains general information only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. It is not personal financial advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice tailored to your circumstances. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance, and benchmark investing does not guarantee positive returns or outperformance. Consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances before making financial decisions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should my financial adviser outperform the market?
Not necessarily. If your portfolio follows a benchmark-based strategy, the objective is generally to capture the returns of the relevant markets, less investment costs and allowing for implementation differences. The broader value of advice should be assessed through the suitability of your strategy and the quality of financial planning.
What does SPIVA tell investors?
SPIVA compares actively managed funds with relevant benchmarks. Its research has found that most active funds in many categories underperform over longer periods. The results vary by asset class and timeframe, and they do not guarantee that benchmark investing will outperform in every period.
What if my portfolio underperforms its benchmark?
Ask your adviser to explain the difference. Check whether the benchmark is appropriate, returns are calculated consistently, and fees, cash holdings, asset allocation and currency exposure have been considered. Persistent unexplained underperformance deserves investigation.
How often should I review my financial adviser?
At least annually is a useful starting point, with additional reviews when your circumstances or goals change. The appropriate frequency depends on your financial needs, investment strategy and agreed service arrangements.
How do I know whether financial advice is worth the cost?
Consider the overall service, not just investment returns. Review the suitability of your strategy, the clarity of recommendations, your progress towards goals, the management of financial risks and the practical value of advice across superannuation, retirement planning and cash flow.